Home: Maucher Jenkins

Intellectual Property

Patents | Trade Marks | Designs

ニュース&イベント

ニュースイベント

Skating on Thin Ice: The Court of Appeal Expands on the Circumstances when an Immaterial Variant may Amount to Patent Infringement

日時: 19 December 2018

By Reuben Jacob and Dr Janet Strath

 

In its decision in Icescape Ltd v Ice-World International BV, the Court of Appeal has considered for the first time the effect of the Supreme Court’s decision in Actavis UK Ltd v Eli Lilly & Co on how patent claims should be construed in the context of infringement allegations. With this judgment, the Court of Appeal recognises expressly that the previous “Protocol Questions” should be abandoned and that from now on the “Actavis Questions” will be applied in order to establish infringement in a case where a variant from the claim achieves substantially the same effect in substantially the same way.

 

On an appeal from a decision of Mr John Baldwin QC (sitting as a deputy judge in the Patents Court), the Court of Appeal had to decide whether the deputy judge had been correct to revoke a European patent for a cooling system for a mobile ice rink, on the basis that it was not entitled to priority and that, had the patent been valid, it would not have been infringed. Lord Kitchin, who gave the lead judgment, held that the deputy judge had been correct to revoke the patent for lacking priority over the claimed priority document. However, the case is of particular importance for Lord Kitchin’s application of the three “Actavis” questions in determining that, had the patent been valid, the variant would have infringed because it varied from the invention in ways which were immaterial.

 

Read our full article in the upcoming (2019) 41 E.I.P.R., Issue 2.

 

Read the decision in full here.

C
このサイトはcookieを使用しています。

cookieの中には重要なものもありますが、このサイトがどのように利用されているかについての情報を提供し、ご利用体験を向上させるために使用されるものもあります。このサイトが使用しているcookieに関する詳しい情報は、「プライバシー保護方針」をご覧ください。

必須Cookie

必須cookieは、中核となる機能を有効化します。ウェブサイトは、このcookieがないと適切な機能を果たすことができません。ご利用のブラウザの設定を使って無効化することが可能です。

分析Cookies

分析cookieは、利用に関する情報を収集・報告することでウェブサイトの改善のために使用されます。

x